Help! Please vote for your favorite photo!

[MiniSimp]

I will be entering one of these photos in to a contest, but have no idea which one to choose...
The theme for the contest is "Glass" open to your interpretation.

HELP!

1.



2.



3.



4.

[ROCKO]

2

[superyota]

3

[Dr.Maxwe001]

I like  #1   it shows Glass thast is in a formal setting

[muddytaco]

i like number 3

[bigarms23]

1

[82juguete]

#4... Implication of glass everywhere, without being too literal and obvious. glass of lens, bokeh which has a glassy reflective quality, and the glassy surface of the water.

[MiniSimp]

Hmmm..... it's still pretty close... 

[emsvitil]

3

But I think like an engineer...........


Don't know how artsy-fartsy judges would vote..

[yoshaleng]

1

[crawlerdan]

crop the word "macys" out and you gotta winner buddy

[46&2]

crop the word "macys" out and you gotta winner buddy

I agree, I think the Macys throws it off a bit for me. 2 or 3 are the best, 2 if you get rid of Macys.

[Goldrush]

id say 3 and 1. 3 being the best, then 1 second best! lol super cool!

[87hillbillyoter]

crop the word "macys" out and you gotta winner buddy

x3

[brainlessfool]

#1 butt I like flowers.

[Stocker]

After studying each of them, 1 & 3 appealed to me the most. The more I went back & forth between them, I had to vote for #1. It strikes me as exceptionally beautiful, with contrasting colors & textures and superb use of light. The gracefulness of the swan reflects (heh) the delicate quality of the glass.  

All are excellent. Good luck in the contest!   

[jrock]

#3.
I liked #2 but something seems off. I like #1 but its not so "out of the ordinary".

[MiniSimp]

You guys are awesome! Keep it coming!
(knew I asked the right people) 

[kneedownnate]

I'd say 3, but judges are probably looking for something more like 1, so 1 if you want to win.

So no pics looking through a scope? 

[MiniSimp]

I've submitted #3
You can see my competition here http://challenges.smugmug.com/Other/DSS-67-Glass/

[PA_taco_13]

   good luck!   I think #3 was a good choice 

[muddytaco]

the only other one i like is the sunlit art.  still think yours is probably the best one there though