So you are saying that a factory 2.28:1 low range gear is messed up? Or does that Crawl Box have a 4.70:1 gear set in it for some reason?
The problem with putting the 4.70:1 gear sets in the Crawl Box in a 21-spline setup, is that the torque leaving the Crawl Box is multiplied so much that by putting that much torque infront of a 21-spline factory input gear will cause it to break/yield. The 21-spline factory input is "fused" between the splines and the seal surface, and the physical size of the fuse is not sufficient to handle the torque coming from a 4.70:1 gear set.
You do know need to be heavy on the throttle for torque to increase to the point of failure. You could be at idle engine speed, and if you get the truck in enough of a bind, the applied torque throughout the drivetrain system will undergo rapid growth, and will break at the weakest link, in this case, the 21-spline factory input gear behind a 4.70:1 Crawl Box.
Regards,
BigMike