personally i would go with a hydraulic, far less likely to overheat, and comes waterproof from the factory (very nice if u do water crossings or mudding), works underwater as well. hydraulics will pull at a faster rate under max load than an electric will, and much quieter. just my
both warn and milemarker are great, personally i'd go for the mm. even if you do have a problem it comes with a warrenty, so y pay the extra money? just have to watch that the cable doesnt build up too much in one spot. not that hard