0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Time for me to play Devil's advocate here:Without a doubt, some people can rebuild a 22R and get plenty of miles out of it. That said, there are some caveats that seem to come up over and over again. -- Poorly done machine work can really ruin an build. If the machine shop goes by the FSM (which, I believe, has pretty lenient tolerances) you probably won't have as good an engine as factory. Unfortunately, you have no control over how good your machine shop is or if they know anything about rebuilding R series engines.-- Experience counts. If this is your first rebuild, it probably won't be as good as your 10th. If you want to keep that engine for hundreds of thousands of miles, your 1st rebuild may not do that.I chose to get an engine from 22RE performance because they have a good reputation and I think their machine work is probably better than any machine shop in my area could do. Plus any place I have to assemble an engine would be full of dirt, sand, or abrasive dust.
... Maybe my tone will change in a thousand miles when my DNJ head gasket decides to give up ...
I'm going to give them a chance.
Check out DOA engines. My friend had one from them and he liked it.
Hey FjordWarrden,That sounds like you are giving them a "chance" to fail, or you are feeing a risk factor.I would not have a rebuild done without the block being sonic tested and magnafluxed. It is interesting that LCE, 22RE Performance, and Yota1 do not mention those tests.That may or many not be what is done to a 30 to 40 year old block, but I’d feel better knowing the block is healthy enough for another 10 years.I’m surprised and somewhat suspicious that if they have built 10,000 engines and why only a few reviews?Their prices are very similar to 22RE Performance when looking at comparable parts, so I would not see price as a factor for my choice.What is their quoted delivery time?Gnarls.
This is a quote from the Yota1 website regarding inspecting the block. "We start with an original Toyota block, crankshaft and rod castings, (not "new" Chinese counterfeit Junk) remove all oil and water plugs. Then it's off to the hot tank for the night, tomorrow morning we will remove the block from the tank, steam clean it, hand brush the oil galleys then clean it again! From there it's off to the inspection station to get magnafluxed, ultrasonic test cylinder wall thickness, check for proper deck height, hone and check main line, inspect all bolt holes, and tons more, well we made it this far so let's bore the cylinders then we can finally decide if we can build this block or if it's off to the scrap bin. "Their quoted delivery time is 5-6 days. All work is done in house.As for my "giving them a chance" your right there is a little doubt there, but not much. I always have doubts when ever I give someone a lot of money for a product I have never tested before. And even then consistency is always questionable now a days.
Gnarly..Wow thats is very cool, where do you find the equations to run cam analysis? I fear I don't know hardly enough about cam shafts to answer your questions.It seems like minimal gains for the money though. I wonder what are the disadvantages of switching cams from stock? If more usable power can be gained through changing the cam timing and duration, why didn't Toyota do it in the first place?I really want to try and build the best 22re I can, but I wonder, didn't Toyota do that in the first place?
Interestingly, Yota1’s 230 cam has the tightest valve lash I’ve seen on any 22 cam. It also has the lowest degrees of valve overlap.
SO what does that translate to in terms of engine performance and longevity? Good cam? Bad cam? Unknown?excellent information!By the way I can't thank you enough for sharing.
Thanks again Gnarls, I will take your advice and talk with Yota1. I am wondering, if they (yota1) claims to have built 10,000 enignes, how come I can't find anyone who has one?!
Started by Rotozuk « 1 2 » Project Research and Build-Ups
Started by BlenDeR Project Research and Build-Ups
Started by Greg55_99 Project Research and Build-Ups
Started by Stabs Project Research and Build-Ups
Started by THEMAN « 1 2 » Engine