Is "BV Carnage" the same as "Carnage Canyon?"  If so, I heard it will be closed very soon.  A friend of mine went with some guy at Off Road Solutions last weekend.

2 different trails.  Technically, BV Carnage is called Carnage Canyon.  I've always called the trail they are closed outside of Boulder "Boulder Carnage" and the one near Buena Vista "BV Carnage".  Both trails get called "Carnage", "Carnage Canyon".

BV Carnage is rated at the 3rd toughest trail in the state (tied with Patriot in Penrose).  Boulder Carnage doesn't even make the top 10.  Boulder Carnage is a good trail but with it being soooooooooooo close to Boulder / Denver, it sees a ton of usage.  With that usage comes stupidity and trail damage.  I hate to see trails close but I'm not too concerned with Boulder Carnage closing.  The only bad thing is all the stupid people will now find other trails to go and destroy.